The story of Shackleton and the Endurance is an incredible tale. I have read a good amount of literature on this expedition simply because I find it so remarkable that after facing such an abundance of deadly obstacles, the entire crew managed to survive. This is, in my opinion, one of the greatest survival stories of all times. Although it took place almost one hundred years ago, the story of the Endurance is still a captivating and uplifting tale that continues to entertain readers even today.
Before this story, all the books I have read on this subject have been text heavy with very few illustrations or pictures present to supplement the dramatic story. This inclusion of photographs is what made this particular book different for me. I am familiar with the story of Shackleton’s journey, but prior to this book I was completely detached from the characters. Associating historic images of the men with their names made the story seem much more realistic and also much more intense. Seeing the men’s faces through photographs is a reminder that these men did exist and that they experienced first hand the traumatic events being described in the book. I felt much more connected to the men and also more invested in the story after being introduced to the sailors through text while being visually exposed to their images captured on the expedition.
As I progressed through the book, I was constantly shocked by the state of morale among the crew. Despite the horrendous conditions the men were faced with, the temperament of the group remained relatively stable. There was not much evidence of disagreeability and only one mild mutiny incident. I would imagine that being stuck for over a year in the Artic would be agonizing, but the men continued to partake in innovative activities that helped pass the time and keep spirits high. It is incredibly impressive that the crew was able to survive at all, but to do so with such courageous and amiable attitudes makes this story all the better.
From a critical perspective, this book strongly relies on the element of conflict to keep the plot in motion. The conflict in this story is a mêlée between self and nature, or to be more specific, the crew vs. the Arctic. The crew is continually trying to survive the hardships brought on by their frozen environment, and it is this struggle between human survival and nature that is the foundation of this story.
Another element that is integral to this story is the setting. Armstrong did an exceptional job illustrating, both visually and textually, the natural brutality of such an environment. Her descriptions of the plummeting climate, the freezing ocean water, and the snow were very vivid, and her choice of visual imagery strongly supplemented her textual descriptions. Armstrong had to capture the Arctic as a setting if she was to make the story realistic for her readers, and I think she did this well.
In conclusion, this book successfully draws the reader in to the frozen world seen from the eyes of the crew. In the book, readers are exposed to the sparse but harsh landscape and conditions that make up the setting of the story. The self against nature conflict is prevalent throughout, and it is the uncertainty of the final conflict resolution that makes the story especially suspenseful for a first time reader. I enjoyed reading this particular book because it made the characters more vivid and real through the use of photography, but also because the tale of Shackleton and the Endurance is a survival story that I will never tire of.
Corrie,
ReplyDeleteI like that you had a lot of prior knowledge before reading this story. I have never heard of this story. I remember reading another nonfiction narrative picture book like Shipwreck, but I think it was about an earlier shipwreck. The men eat each other and/or die of scurvy. I thought that was what Shipwreck was going to be about, so I was pleasantly surprised. However, after reading this book I don't know if I would want to know more. I found the story interesting, but not captivating.I just found some parts to be too informational even with the pictures. I am also a person who needs a little love story and there was not even a hint of that going on.
I do think this story needs to be told, and I can understand why people find it captivating. It is a great story to analyze the courage of the men. I also like that you pulled out the theme of man vs nature. I also liked that you used the word melee. I totally forgot about that word, and I am glad you used it because it's back in my lexicon.
I was also shocked by the morale of the crew. I think if it would have been just cold it would have been bearable. However, it was cold and WET. The worst combo ever. I liked how in class you described feeling "skirmish." That's a good way to put it. That is how I felt with the wet and cold imagery. I also think that is a compliment to the author for creating a mood like that in her novel.